Admitting I was correct in each and every argument I raised in support of the remand apparently annoyed the good Judge James E. Boasberg so much he felt compelled to spend a good deal of the order hurling ad hominem arguments towards me. Also, his obiter dicta regarding the issues surrounding the Article V convention are not only unnecessary, but for a federal judge to fail to understand the mechanics of Article V is embarrassing. In particular, Judge Boasberg writes in his order of remand: "Nor need they be, according to pro se Plaintiff Montgomery Blair Sibley. For, he says, thirty-five states – more than the two-thirds required by Article V – have already voiced their support for a constitutional convention . . ."
Yet this is simply wrong. The 35 states have not called for a "constitutional convention" but instead only what they are allowed to "call" for under Article V: A convention to propose amendments. Seriously, a federal judge not understanding the constitution?
That all said, now the battle returns to D.C. Superior Court where the playing field is a bit more level than in the federal court.
More as it happens.

2 comments:
Excellent Monty. Eagerly awaiting your next post.
Was there ever a number of states with active applications they agreed to as a matter of fact? How could that be determined without counting?
Post a Comment
Play nice!